Counterterrorism Blog
The first multi-expert blog dedicated solely to counterterrorism issues, serving as a gateway to the community for policymakers and serious researchers. Designed to provide realtime information about terrorism cases and policy developments.
 

Al-Qaida Takes Casualties in Iraq -- But Apparently Not Zarqawi

By Evan Kohlmann

Despite recent reports to the contrary, Al-Qaida's Committee in Iraq has suffered numerous casualties during recent combat operations in northern and western Iraq -- including both native and foreign fighters.  As I hinted at in my previous post on Iraq's foreign fighters, at least four commanders from the designated foreign terrorist organization Asbat al-Ansar in southern Lebanon have been killed during intense fighting near the western towns of Al-Qaim and Al-KarabilahAnother Yemeni national -- a veteran of multiple trips to Afghanistan -- was also slain before he could participate in an intended suicide bombing mission.

Other, highly dubious reports have also surfaced in the media today suggesting that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi may have been himself killed in the northern Iraqi city of Mosul during a U.S. military raid on a suspected Al-Qaida hideout.  Needless to say, such "tips" are often posted on fringe Arabic-language message forums on the Internet and are subsequently picked up by overeager news agencies -- but ultimately, most prove to be nothing more than unfounded rumor.  Certainly, Al-Qaida doesn't seem to have been at all fazed by the reported Mosul raid.  Not only has Al-Qaida issued nearly twenty new communiques in the last twenty four hours, but it also claimed credit for additional insurgent attacks on U.S. forces in Mosul.  Apparently, the raid that "might have killed" Zarqawi did not even succeed in decapitating Al-Qaida's military command structure in the Mosul area.  This Zarqawi report ultimately will be proven or disproven by the only sure way possible: forensic evidence collected on scene.  But, at least for the moment--given what we do know--it seems fair to classify Zarqawi's would-be passing as extremely unlikely.

See: (UPI) Reports of Zarqawi's death played down

UPDATE: I've fixed the broken link to the Asbat al-Ansar PDF file

UPDATE II [11/21/05, 9:30am EST]: An Al-Qaida supporter who claims to know the identities of those inside the destroyed house in Mosul has emphatically denied that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi was present in the structure or was killed during the raid.  According to the source, a total of eight individuals were hiding in the residence at the time, including seven male insurgents and one of their wives.  This group had not yet been involved in significant insurgent operations, but rather was preparing to carry out a "terrorist martyrdom mission."  Furthermore, according to the source, the raid that led to the deaths of the would-be "suicide squad" was executed exclusively by U.S. military forces--and not Iraqi soldiers or policemen.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://counterterrorismblog.org/mt/pings.cgi/2121

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Al-Qaida Takes Casualties in Iraq -- But Apparently Not Zarqawi:

» Is Abu dead?... from Speed of Thought...
There is at least one report he is. Hmmm. Update: Then there is this, Eight high-ranking al Qaeda leaders kill themselves. [Read More]

» Zarqawi Zonked from alphabet city
Evan Kohlmann weighs in: "But, at least for the moment--given what we do know--it seems fair to classify Zarqawi's would-be passing as extremely unlikely. [Read More]

» Zarqawi may be dead from Media Lies
I've been watching this story for the past 24 hours. Now it seems to be breaking. Eight terrorists died in Mosul when they blew up the house they were... [Read More]

» Al Zarqawi Meets God? from The Strata-Sphere
UPDATE III: This update comes from the Counterterrorism Blog and provides good news irregardless of whether Zarqawi was among the AQ recently killed in Iraq. It also has a major dousing of cold water in it. Despite recent reports to the contrary, A... [Read More]

» Al-Qaida Takes Casualties in Iraq -- But Apparently Not Zarqawi from Law, Terrorism & Homeland Security- Greg McNeal
One has to wonder though, if we did capture Zarqawi, would it be prudent to announce that immediately, or is it best to let the enemy wonder, and to have a chance to gather as much intelligence information as possible from him. In any ca... [Read More]

» Is Zarqawi Dead? from BLACKFIVE
Maybe. Maybe not. There are all kinds of reports about the US checking the DNA of the bodies of seven or eight terrorists killed in a raid in northern Mosul. Pure speculation: Zarqawi's latest attack on Jordan created a difficult [Read More]

» MIDDLE EAST WEEK IN REVIEW, 11/21/05 from Security Watchtower
The most important Middle East news stories from the past week: Al-Hayat reports that both the Jordanian government as well as the Jordanian press and civic groups strongly reject Zarqawi's declared conditions for ending attacks in Jordan. The article ... [Read More]

» MIDDLE EAST WEEK IN REVIEW, 11/21/05 from Security Watchtower
The most important Middle East news stories from the past week: Al-Hayat reports that both the Jordanian government as well as the Jordanian press and civic groups strongly reject Zarqawi's declared conditions for ending attacks in Jordan. The article ... [Read More]

» Zarqawi: Still Not Dead from Don Surber
Well, this is no fun. reports al-Zarqawi may not be dead in Iraq. Osma bin Laden still lives after 4 years. Is the plan to keep 'em alive so we can track 'em -- or are our Muslim allies really not ourallies -- or is the CIA too busy trying to discr... [Read More]

» - Al-Zarqawi may have been killed in Mosul from Secular Blasphemy
TITLE: - Al-Zarqawi may have been killed in Mosul URL: http://blogs.salon.com/0001561/2005/11/21.html#a8531 IP: 80.202.105.174 BLOG NAME: Secular Blasphemy DATE: 11/21/2005 08:22:23 AM [Read More]

» The Blinding of Samson in Iraq (UPDATED) from All Things Beautiful
AL-ZARQAWI MAY BE DEAD (AGAIN)? Unlikely, according to Evan @ The Counterterrorism Blog.... [Read More]

» Taking Down Rabid Islamist Swine from Rhymes With Right
Or at least those are the reports coming out of Iraq. MOSUL, Iraq (AP) - U.S. and Iraqi forces raided a farmhouse in northern Iraq at dawn Saturday, searching for suspected members of al-Qaida in Iraq. Eight insurgents and four... [Read More]

» Zarqawi Still Alive, The Left Celebrates from The Jawa Report
The White House is now saying that it is "highly unlikely" that Abu Musab al Zarqawi died in a Mosul raid Saturday. Earlier Jawa post from Traderrob here. *Sigh* Not that killing the al Qaeda in Iraq leader--and the man... [Read More]

» Zarqawi Still Alive, The Left Celebrates from The Jawa Report
The White House is now saying that it is "highly unlikely" that Abu Musab al Zarqawi died in a Mosul raid Saturday. Earlier Jawa post from Traderrob here. *Sigh* Not that killing the al Qaeda in Iraq leader--and the man... [Read More]

» Did al-Zarqawi finally get his due? from Small Town Veteran
... When [Zarqawi] finally meets his 72 virgins, here's betting they're all 300 pound males who think he's just the cutest little thing they've ever seen. [Read More]

» Al-Zarqawi: dead or not? from Tel-Chai Nation
There have been reports already, such as this one from the Jerusalem Post (via Michelle Malkin), that Abu-Musab al-Zarqawi may have been among eight terrorists who blew themselves up in Mosul in Iraq. But so far, nothing is clear. [Read More]